Yep, syntax problem, change it to:
mail($to,$HTTP_POST_VARS['title'],$body,"From: {$HTTP_POST_VARS['email']}");
There are several ways to use arrays in strings, the above is one of them. Or don't put it in the string and do:
mail($to,$HTTP_POST_VARS['title'],$body,"From: ". $HTTP_POST_VARS['email']);
BTW, you should validate the data and in the VERY least make sure it's not empty first.