Have each link have a GET variable after it.
$clickedon = $_GET['clickedon'];
if(isset($clickedon)) {
echo "You clicked on ".$clickedon;
echo "<br><A href=\"thispage.php\">Try again?</a>";
} else {
echo "<a href=\"thispage.php?clickedon=button1\">Click here for option 1</a>";
echo "<a href=\"thispage.php?clickedon=button2\">Click here for option 2</a>";
}