Yup. Exactly. It gets a little more bizarre... as I near the ~1300 record limit, I start to see the problem intermittently. As I add more records, the problem gets worse until it doesn't work at all.
When I begin to see the problem, I can actually refresh the details page by pressing <F5> once or twice and most times it'll bring up the record. However, that works less and less often as I get more records into the system.
As info, the details page just does a select on the single record using the record id. It's pretty straightforward, I think.