thanx for the reply!
It's the "2 separate calls to the mail function" that I can't figure out.
I've tried various ways but they only result in one email.
No luck searching for an answer on google either...
UPDATE!
It works! We were both right. I just had to get my 'if else' statements in the right order.
I made 2 sets of variables and did the following:
if(mail($to,$subject,$message,$headers));
if(mail($to2,$subject2,$message,$headers2));
this sends the same message but with different subjects and reply addresses to the webmaster and the client.