You could simply use [man]array_keys/man instead if you want multiple matches. Example (nevvermind's post with two small modifications):
<?php
$lines = file('YourFile.txt', FILE_IGNORE_NEW_LINES);
$email = 'zach@loud.com';
$match_index = array_keys($lines, $email);
foreach($match_index as $index) {
echo "MATCH: <font color=red>Line #" . (string)($index + 1) . "</font> : $lines[$match_index] <br />\n";
}
EDIT: Also, don't forget to mark this thread resolved (if it is) using the link on the Thread Tools menu above.