John, thanks for the reply.
I looked at dd.crom.ru's dbg; it requires a separate IDE ...it does support PHPEdit (buggy but decent, open source) and a couple of other (non-free) IDEs.
I'll try the Komodo IDE. Zend's decision to go with Java kills it for me (LOL, snail on valium is about right). APD has a great looking site but the product is at v0.1 so that tells me to stay away.
So far DBG seems to be the best choice for the debugger side-- it does interface with Microsoft's IDE, which for better or for worse, is a world-class tool that I trust. But I haaaate the idea of switching to Microsoft. :-(
IMHO, what we really need:
Existing editors like UltraEdit, TextPad, etc. to support debugging hooks. So DBG will work.
More debuggers that easily run on Windows. I ultimately deploy to a Linux server but prefer to do my dev on a Win XP laptop. I don't want to get into doing my own compiles, though I recognize that this is part of the trade-off of using Open Source (or just plain free!) products. Just saying that getting these tools in a more Installer-friendly, ready-to-run form is probably a smart move for the evolution of PHP as a platform.
Broadly speaking-- combining 1 and 2-- better PHP support in IDEs, whether that's existing IDEs (HomeSite) or new ones (PHPEdit). Everyone's working on this one, and it's heartening, and if I had more time right now I'd contribute to PHPEdit's development as it seems to be coming along well and have the most potential. But speaking as a USER now, I spend hours every day writing code, and for now can't switch away from my (mature, solid, stable, supported) UltraEdit. Alas.
Anyhow, thanks for letting me rant for a sec, just some random thoughts on the state of PHP development environments. I'll check out those sites you mention.
best,
Eric
http://ericmueller.org